Future Value, Present Value and the Time Value Principle
Two facts anchor everything in finance: a rupee today is worth more than a rupee tomorrow (time value of money), and risk and return go hand in hand, so a safe rupee is worth more than a risky one. Future value (FV) is the value of cash at some point in the future; present value (PV) is the value today of cash to be received in the future. The module builds tools to move cash flows across time (compounding and discounting), shortcut formulas for recurring patterns (perpetuities, growing perpetuities, annuities, growing annuities), and the link between quoted and actual interest (APR and EAR).
Future value: compounding
Invest ₹100 for a year at 7% per year compounded annually: principal ₹100 plus interest 7% of 100 = ₹7, so FV after 1 year is . Leave it a second year: the new principal is ₹107, interest is , and
Second-year interest (7.49) exceeds first-year interest (7) because interest is earned on previously earned interest. That is compound interest. Under simple interest the interest is the same ₹7 every year. Compound interest is the regime used throughout the course.
The longer the horizon and the higher the rate , the greater the FV. Moving cash forward in time is compounding.
Present value: discounting
PV is the exact reverse of FV. To get ₹114.49 at the end of year 2 at 7%, divide by :
- is the discount rate, because it is used to discount future cash flows. It is also the opportunity cost (of capital): by committing money to a project you give up the chance to earn the prevailing market return on an investment of similar risk.
- The discount factor is the PV of ₹1 received after years. It moves inversely to the discount rate: higher , lower .
- Higher (longer wait) lowers PV. Higher lowers PV; a riskier cash flow deserves a higher and so is worth less, because investors care about risk as well as return.
- Moving cash back in time is discounting; moving it forward is compounding.
| Compounding | Discounting | |
|---|---|---|
| Direction | Today future | Future today |
| Operation | Multiply by | Divide by |
| Output | Future value | Present value |
Comparing cash flows: PV and FV give the same answer
Compare options only at a common point in time (apples to apples).
- ₹100 today vs. ₹100 in 2 years: today is better (time value).
- ₹100 today vs. ₹110 in 2 years: depends on the opportunity cost. If the market would give more than ₹110 on ₹100 over 2 years, take the ₹100 now; if less, wait for ₹110.
With :
| Method | ₹100 today | ₹110 in 2 years | Choose |
|---|---|---|---|
| PV (today) | ₹100 | ₹100 today | |
| FV (year 2) | ₹110 | ₹100 today |
Both methods always lead to the same decision.
Negative interest rates
whenever . In practice can be below zero: Japan and some European countries have had negative interest rates. In a positive-rate world the bank pays you interest on deposits and the central bank pays banks on theirs; with negative rates the bank charges you.
- It is a monetary policy tool (covered in Macroeconomics) for a downturn (falling economic activity) with deflation (falling prices, opposite of inflation, rising prices).
- Under deflation consumers postpone purchases, deepening the downturn. Negative rates discourage deposits (even a locker costs money) and push people to spend; for corporations borrowing becomes cheaper. The aim is to prop up the economy.
- Negative rates violate the time-value principle but are expected to be temporary, so the course assumes positive interest rates.
Key takeaways
- (compounding); (discounting).
- is both the discount rate and the opportunity cost of capital, i.e. the market return on an equal-risk investment.
- Longer wait or higher (more risk) means lower PV; falls as rises.
- Compare at a single date; PV and FV comparisons agree.
- Negative rates are a temporary policy tool; assume .
PV of Multiple Cash Flows, NPV and Rate of Return
Discounted cash flow (DCF)
To value a stream of cash flows, discount each one and add them up. For a -year project paying :
This is the discounted cash flow (DCF) formula, one of the most powerful in finance. It values any asset (bond, share, project, company) provided its cash flows can be estimated. PV does not include the initial investment.
Net present value and the NPV rule
Sign convention: cash inflows are positive, outflows negative.
- The goal of the corporation is to maximise shareholder wealth. A positive-NPV (value-adding) project raises shareholder wealth, so accept if , reject if .
- NPV falls as the discount rate (opportunity cost) rises.
Rate of return
Invest ₹100, receive ₹150 after a year: . This formula applies to a single-year project only, not a multi-year one.
Rate of return rule: accept if the return exceeds the opportunity cost of capital. A small positive return is not enough; it must well exceed the opportunity cost.
Example 1: office block, sure payoff
Cost of land and construction is $700,000 (paid from cash in the bank). The advisor forecasts a sale next year for $800,000 for sure. Safe US Treasury securities (government debt) yield 7%; the stock market is risky and averages 12%.
Opportunity cost. It is the market return at the same risk as the project's cash flows. The $800,000 is certain, so the benchmark is the risk-free government bond rate: .
Timeline: : ; : .
Positive, so accept.
Accept. NPV and the rate of return rule give the same decision.
Market value, project risk and NPV
- If markets price assets fairly (assumed throughout the course), market value = present value. Immediately after paying $700,000, you could sell the project for its PV, $747,664. You gain $47K instantly because the project is value-adding.
- Unrealistic assumption: the $800,000 is only the advisor's best forecast, not certain. If uncertain, the opportunity cost rises, PV falls below $747K, and investors would not pay $747K (investing $747K in government securities does give a sure $800K; this project does not). You would have to cut your asking price.
- If the project is as risky as the stock market, :
Still positive, so still accept, but NPV is lower because is higher.
Example 2: choosing between alternatives by NPV
Same $700,000 office block, with risk equal to the stock market, so for both options.
- Option 1: sell for $800,000 at end of year 1.
- Option 2: rent for 2 years at $30,000 per year (received at each year end), then sell for $840,000. Year-2 cash flow is .
Pick the option with the higher NPV: Option 2.
Unrealistic assumption: the building is ready instantly; in reality it must be built before it can be rented.
Maximum upfront investment. If the upfront cost is not fixed, a rational investor will pay up to the amount that keeps NPV from turning negative, i.e. the PV of the option's cash flows (about $720K for Option 2).
Key takeaways
- DCF: excludes the initial outlay; .
- Accept if (value-adding, raises shareholder wealth); higher lowers NPV.
- Rate of return (single-year only); accept if it exceeds the opportunity cost.
- Opportunity cost depends on the risk of the project's cash flows: certain cash flows use the risk-free rate.
- With fair markets, market value = PV; the maximum price worth paying for an asset is its PV.
Perpetuities and Shifting Cash Flows
Shortcuts replace term-by-term discounting for four recurring patterns: perpetuity, growing perpetuity, annuity, growing annuity.
Perpetuity
A perpetuity is the same cash flow every year, forever.
Its PV is an infinite sum:
An infinite series can still have a finite sum if each term is a fraction of the previous one. This is a geometric series with sum provided . Here first term and common ratio , which lies between 0 and 1 because . So
This is the value one period before the first cash flow.
Shifting cash flows
If the first cash flow arrives at , is the value at ; to get the PV (value at ) shift it 2 periods left, giving .
| Shift | Operation |
|---|---|
| 1 period left (earlier) | Divide by |
| periods left | Divide by |
| 1 period right (later) | Multiply by |
| periods right | Multiply by |
(E.g. at year 1 is equivalent to today and at year 2.)
Applying perpetuities
billion per year from year 1, :
If nothing is received for 3 years (first cash flow at ), bn is the value at ; shift 3 periods left:
Lower, because the first three years pay nothing.
Key takeaways
- Perpetuity: , valid because the common ratio .
- The formula gives value one period before the first cash flow.
- Shift left: divide by ; shift right: multiply by .
- A delayed start lowers PV.
Annuities
An annuity is the same cash flow every year for a fixed number of years (a -year annuity, last cash flow at year ).
The PV is a finite geometric series with terms. The sum of terms is (). With , , :
The term is the -year annuity factor. Again the value sits one period before the first payment.
Example: Tiburon Autos
$5,000 per year at year end for 5 years, no down payment, . What does the car really cost?
Example: state lottery (ignoring time value)
Advertised jackpot of ₹365 million paid as 30 yearly installments of ₹12.167 million at each year end; . The ₹365M is just , adding cash received at different dates (adding apples and oranges). The true value is a 30-year annuity:
Less than half the advertised amount.
Annuity due: payments at the beginning of each year
If the 30 payments start today (beginning of each year; last at end of year 29), PV rises because every payment comes one period earlier. The annuity formula values the stream one period before the first payment, i.e. at (₹167.5M). Shift 1 period right:
Loan amortisation
A loan is repaid over its term as principal plus interest, typically via EMIs (equated monthly installments); part of each payment is interest, part is principal. Amortising a loan means repaying principal so the outstanding balance falls. (Annual payments are used here for simplicity.)
Interest each year beginning balance; principal repaid = payment interest; ending balance = beginning balance principal repaid; ending balance becomes next year's beginning balance.
Variant 1: equal annual payments
$1,000, 4-year loan at 10%, equal payments at year end. The loan amount is the PV of the annuity payments, so solve for :
| Year | Beginning balance | Payment | Interest (10%) | Principal | Ending balance |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1,000 | 315.47 | 100.00 | 215.47 | 784.53 |
| 2 | 784.53 | 315.47 | 78.45 | 237.02 | 547.51 |
| 3 | 547.51 | 315.47 | 54.75 | 260.72 | 286.79 |
| 4 | 286.79 | 315.47 | 28.68 | 286.79 | 0 |
(The lecture works years 1 and 2 with rounded figures: interest 100 then 78, principal 215 then 237, balance about 784 then 547.) Year 3: payment about $315, interest about $55, principal about $261, balance remaining about $287.
Pattern: interest declines (balance falls), principal repayment rises, total payment constant. The ending balance in year 4 must be zero; a materially non-zero value signals an error (rounding gives only a tiny residual).
Variant 2: equal principal repayments
Same loan, but principal of $250 is repaid each year plus interest on the balance.
| Year | Beginning balance | Interest (10%) | Principal | Total payment | Ending balance |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1,000 | 100 | 250 | 350 | 750 |
| 2 | 750 | 75 | 250 | 325 | 500 |
| 3 | 500 | 50 | 250 | 300 | 250 |
| 4 | 250 | 25 | 250 | 275 | 0 |
Pattern: interest declines, principal constant, total payment declines.
| Variant 1 (equal payments) | Variant 2 (equal principal) | |
|---|---|---|
| Interest | Falls | Falls |
| Principal | Rises | Constant |
| Total payment | Constant | Falls |
| PV of payments at 10% | $1,000 | $1,000 |
The PV of payments equals the amount borrowed in both variants; they differ only in timing.
Key takeaways
- Annuity: , valued one period before the first payment.
- Never sum undiscounted payments across years (lottery trap).
- Annuity due ordinary annuity .
- Equal-payment loans: solve from PV = loan; interest falls, principal rises; balance reaches 0.
- Any amortisation scheme has PV of payments = loan amount.
Growing Perpetuities and Growing Annuities
Growing perpetuity
A growing perpetuity pays at the end of year 1 and grows at constant rate forever:
Geometric with and . Convergence needs , i.e. :
If the terms do not shrink and the sum explodes. No real asset has infinite PV, so must hold. is the value one period before the first cash flow (first cash flow at year 3 means value at , then divide by ).
Growing annuity
A growing annuity pays at year 1, growing at per year, for years: last cash flow is .
Finite geometric series with , , (formula needs , i.e. ):
Special case:
The formula cannot be used, and PV is not infinite (only finite terms). Each term simplifies:
so there are identical terms:
Example: club membership
Fee ₹5,000 at end of the coming year, rising 6% per year, 3 years; or pay ₹12,750 today. . Choose the lower PV of costs.
Option 1 (annual fees: 5,000, 5,000×1.06, 5,000×1.06²) is a growing annuity:
Check term by term: gives the same.
Option 2: PV (paid today). It is cheaper, so take the 3-year membership.
The four shortcuts are one family
Start from the growing annuity formula:
| Pattern | Setting in growing-annuity formula | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Ordinary annuity | ||
| Growing perpetuity | , (so ) | |
| Perpetuity | and | |
| Growing annuity, | (separate case) |
Worked example: all four shortcuts
At compounded annually, how much must be set aside for each scheme (all pay $1 billion at the end of year 1)?
| Part | Pattern | Computation | PV |
|---|---|---|---|
| A. $1bn each year forever | Perpetuity | $12.5 bn | |
| B. Growing 4% forever | Growing perpetuity () | $25 bn | |
| C. $1bn per year for 20 years | 20-year annuity | $9.818 bn | |
| D. Growing 4% for 19 more years (20 payments) | Growing annuity () | $13.247 bn | |
| E. Growing 8% for 19 more years | Growing annuity, | $18.519 bn |
E > D because cash flows grow faster in E than in D.
Key takeaways
- Growing perpetuity: , requires ; is the first cash flow.
- Growing annuity: for ; for .
- All formulas value the stream one period before the first cash flow.
- Set and/or in the growing-annuity formula to recover the other three.
APR, EAR and Compounding Frequency
Cash flows and compounding need not be annual. Compare two ₹100 fixed deposits at "10% per year":
- Bank A, annual compounding: after a year.
- Bank B, semi-annual compounding (5% every half year): ₹105 after six months, then after a year.
Bank B's ₹110.25 equals 10.25% compounded annually. So 5% per half year 10% per year compounded semi-annually 10.25% per year compounded annually.
Definitions
- Periodic interest ratethe rate per compounding period (5% per half year).
- APR (annual percentage rate)a yearly rate that may be compounded at any interval, so the compounding interval must be stated. Obtained by annualising the periodic rate with simple interest (periodic rate ): .
- EAR (effective annual rate)a yearly rate compounded annually. Obtained by annualising the periodic rate with compound interest (5% in the first half, 5.25% in the second): 10.25%.
= number of compounding intervals per year: semi-annual 2, quarterly 4, monthly 12, daily 365.
Example: APR 10% compounded semi-annually, : , so .
- If : . If : strictly.
Future value with any compounding frequency
Since :
Here is the periodic rate and is the total number of periods; the unit of time becomes the period (day, week, month, quarter, half-year or year).
In banking practice
Banks quote APR (on deposits and loans), but interest is actually paid at the EAR.
Yes Bank FD: 6.65% per year compounded quarterly (Indian banks compound quarterly), ₹1 lakh for a year. This is an APR, not an EAR.
On deposits the bank pays more than the quoted rate; on loans you actually pay the EAR, which exceeds the quoted APR.
Example: compounding frequency
$10 million at 6% for 4 years:
- A. Annual (, APR = EAR): million.
- B. Monthly (): million.
More frequent compounding gives a higher FV.
Discounting periodic cash flows
Cash flows that occur every period are discounted at the periodic rate , with time measured in periods.
Example: $5 every six months for 3 years; discount rate 10% per year compounded semi-annually. Periodic rate ; half-years; this is a 6-period annuity:
Key takeaways
- APR is quoted (simple annualisation, needs compounding interval); EAR is what is actually earned or paid (compound annualisation).
- ; when , equal when .
- : more frequent compounding gives higher FV.
- Match the rate to the cash-flow frequency: periodic cash flows, periodic rate .
Revise before your examAll 6 exam tips from this module in one list
- Do not confuse the discount rate with the discount factor . They are inversely related.
- Choose between mutually competing options by the higher NPV computed at the same ; the maximum you should pay upfront equals the PV of the cash flows.
- The universal rule: (and the annuity and growing formulas below) values the stream one period before the first cash flow. Identify where the first cash flow sits, then shift to .
- Beginning-of-period annuity PV = (ordinary annuity PV) .
- First classify the pattern (forever or finite? growing or flat?), find when the first cash flow occurs, apply the formula, then shift to . Check for growing perpetuities.
- Never treat a quoted APR with as an annual compounded rate; convert to EAR first (or use the periodic rate and number of periods). The classic trap is 6.65% quarterly giving ₹1,06,820, not ₹1,06,650.
Test yourself on this module
Questions from these notes, one at a time, with feedback. Your weak topics are saved.