Term 7 · Module 2 of 9

Overview

Corporate Finance

Practise this module in Claude, ChatGPT or Gemini

Set it up free
Mind map

Two Principles of Finance

Corporate finance rests on two ideas that every rational person already uses intuitively. Both are drawn out by simple choice questions.

Two Principles of Finance

Principle 1: Time value of money

Choose between (1) ₹1 lakh today for sure and (2) ₹1 lakh exactly one year from now for sure. Neither carries risk, yet almost everyone picks today. Reason: ₹1 lakh received today can be put in, say, a bank fixed deposit and become more than ₹1 lakh in a year, and a rational person prefers more to less.

Principle 2: Risk and return

Choose between (1) ₹1 lakh with 100% probability and (2) ₹2 lakh with 50% probability and nothing with 50% probability.

Expected value is the probability-weighted outcome:

E(Choice 1)=1,00,000×1=Rs. 1,00,000E(\text{Choice 1}) = 1{,}00{,}000 \times 1 = \text{Rs. }1{,}00{,}000

E(Choice 2)=2,00,000×0.5+0×0.5=Rs. 1,00,000E(\text{Choice 2}) = 2{,}00{,}000 \times 0.5 + 0 \times 0.5 = \text{Rs. }1{,}00{,}000

The expected values are equal; only the risk differs. Most people still choose the safe option because people are risk-averse: a safe rupee is worth more than a risky rupee. The same logic applies to a fixed salary of ₹1 lakh per month versus an all-variable salary of ₹2 lakh (company does well, 50%) or nothing (company does badly, 50%).

Making the risk-averse person indifferent. Raise the probability of ₹2 lakh from 50% to 60% (nothing falls to 40%). Then:

E(Choice 2)=2,00,000×0.6+0×0.4=Rs. 1,20,000E(\text{Choice 2}) = 2{,}00{,}000 \times 0.6 + 0 \times 0.4 = \text{Rs. }1{,}20{,}000

The higher expected value is the extra return/premium demanded to compensate for bearing extra risk. Hence risk and return go hand in hand.

Principle Statement Why
Time value of money ₹1 today > ₹1 later Money today can be invested to earn more
Risk and return Safe ₹1 > risky ₹1; more risk demands more return Investors are risk-averse and want a premium for extra risk

Key takeaways

  • Money has time value: earlier receipt is worth more.
  • Expected value = probability-weighted outcome.
  • Investors are risk-averse; a safe rupee beats a risky rupee of equal expected value.
  • Bearing extra risk requires a higher expected return (premium).
  • Both principles are used throughout the course.

Forms of Business Organisation

Sole proprietorship

A business owned by one person (the proprietor); suited to small businesses not expected to grow much (e.g. a freelancer). India has no specific law regulating it.

Partnership (general partnership)

Two or more persons form the business; owners are partners who often know each other intimately. Minimum 2, maximum 50 partners. Regulated by the Indian Partnership Act, 1932.

Features common to proprietorships and partnerships

  • Unlimited liability: liability is not capped at the wealth contributed at start; personal wealth can be seized if the business cannot repay what it owes.
  • Limited life: the business ends if the sole proprietor or any partner dies.
  • Tax advantage: no separate income tax on the business. Business income becomes part of the owner's personal income, taxed at the personal slab rate.

Company (corporation)

A separate legal entity: it can sue and be sued. Owners are shareholders; the number allowed depends on whether it is private or public. Regulated by the Indian Companies Act, 2013.

  • Limited liability: shareholders can lose no more than the wealth they contributed in buying shares; personal wealth is safe even if the company cannot repay its debts.
  • Perpetual life: the company survives managers quitting or being dismissed, and shareholders can sell shares to new investors without disrupting operations. Hence it is a going concern, continuing until an event such as bankruptcy or acquisition.
  • Double taxation (financial disadvantage): the company pays corporate income tax to the government, and dividends paid out to shareholders are taxed again in their hands.

Private vs public limited companies (India)

Feature Private limited Public limited
Minimum shareholders 2 7
Maximum shareholders 200 No restriction
Minimum paid-up capital None required ₹5 lakh
Share transferability Restricted Freely transferable
Name suffix Pvt. Ltd. (e.g. Tata Sons Private Limited) Limited only (e.g. Tata Steel Limited)

The key difference is share transferability. "Limited" at the end of both names signals that owners' liability is limited.

Public does not mean listed. A public limited company may be unlisted. Example: BSE Limited is listed (on the NSE), while NSE India Limited is a public limited company but, as of the lecture, unlisted and planning an IPO. Indian regulations do not allow a stock exchange to list its shares on itself, so BSE had to list on the NSE and NSE would list on the BSE.

Hybrid forms

Hybrid Combines Features
Limited liability partnership (LLP) Partnership + corporation Separate legal entity, perpetual existence, limited liability for limited partners
One-person company (OPC) Sole proprietorship + corporation Limited liability for the sole member/shareholder; taxed like a corporation; regulated under Companies Act 2013

Comparison

Sole proprietorship Partnership Company
Owners 1 proprietor 2 to 50 partners Shareholders
Law in India None specific Partnership Act 1932 Companies Act 2013
Liability Unlimited Unlimited Limited
Life Limited Limited Perpetual
Separate legal entity No No Yes
Business-level tax No (taxed as personal income) No (taxed as personal income) Yes (double taxation)

Key takeaways

  • Proprietorships and partnerships: unlimited liability, limited life, no separate business tax.
  • Companies: separate legal entity, limited liability, perpetual life, but double taxation.
  • Private: 2 to 200 shareholders, no minimum capital, restricted transfer. Public: at least 7 shareholders, ₹5 lakh paid-up capital, freely transferable shares.
  • LLP and OPC blend partnership/proprietorship with corporate limited liability.

Corporate Investment and Financing Decisions

Investments, real assets and financial assets

An investment is spending money today in the hope of making more money, or getting some benefit, in the future. It can be in real or financial assets.

Asset type Definition Examples
Real asset (tangible) Asset used to produce goods and services Property, plant, equipment, unsold goods on store shelves
Real asset (intangible) Real asset that cannot be touched Patent, company reputation for customer service, negotiation skills of the sales force
Financial asset A financial claim on the cash flows generated by real assets Shares, bonds, a 5% stake (shareholding) in your main supplier

Link: real assets produce goods and services, which generate cash flows; financial assets are claims on those cash flows.

Investment and financing decisions

Firms invest in real assets to produce goods and services that generate income. These must be funded. Sources of funds:

  • Existing cash reserves
  • Borrowing from a bank or financial institution
  • Borrowing from the public by issuing bonds
  • Issuing additional shares
  1. 1Financing decision: raise money by selling financial assets
  2. 2Investment decision: buy and manage real assets
  3. 3Goods and services
  4. 4Cash flows
Then it starts again from step 1.

The financial manager faces two broad questions:

  1. What investments should the company make? This is the investment decision.
  2. How should the company pay for them? This is the financing decision.

Investment decision: spending money to buy real assets, and also managing assets already in place and disposing of them when their utility ends. Financing decision: raising money by selling financial assets, and also meeting the obligations that arise from raising it (e.g. repaying a loan with interest over its term).

Example. Meta's acquisition of WhatsApp for $22 billion in 2014 was an inorganic investment (investment decision). Meta paid with cash and its own shares (financing decision).

Key takeaways

  • Real assets produce goods and services; financial assets are claims on the resulting cash flows.
  • Corporate finance is primarily about investment and financing decisions.
  • Each decision includes the "after" phase: managing/disposing of assets, and servicing the obligations of financing.
  • Intangibles (patents, reputation, skills) are still real assets.

Cash Flows Between Corporations and Financial Markets

A firm is a bundle of real assets; financial markets comprise investors who hold financial assets, such as shares and bonds. The financial manager connects the two: cash is raised from financial markets and invested in the firm to purchase real assets. Those assets produce goods and services, which are sold to customers and generate cash. The manager then decides whether to retain and reinvest some of that cash in the firm or pay it out as dividends or return it to investors in another form.

Financial Goal of a Corporation

Shareholder wealth maximisation

Large firms have huge numbers of owners (Infosys had over 2 million shareholders holding over 4 billion shares as of 31 March 2026). They cannot all run the firm without chaos, so shareholders delegate authority to professional managers.

Shareholders differ in age, tastes, time horizon, risk tolerance and investment strategy. Delegation works only if shareholders share a common objective. Since people prefer more wealth to less, the common objective is to maximise shareholder wealth, i.e. maximise the current stock price of the firm. Managers do this by accepting value-adding investment projects (how to identify them is covered later).

Shareholder wealth vs profit maximisation

The two are not strictly the same, because of the difference between stock and flow variables.

Stock variable Flow variable
Measured At a point in time Over a period of time
Examples Wealth; all balance sheet items (assets, liabilities, equity) Income, profit; all income statement items
Statement label "Balance sheet as of 31 March 2026" "Income statement for the year"

Wealth is a stock; profit is a flow, so maximising one need not maximise the other.

Why profit maximisation is a poor goal. A manager told to maximise current-year profit can cut R&D and employee-training expenses. Current profit rises, but long-term profit falls. Maximising current-year profit is therefore not a good objective; shareholder wealth is.

Key takeaways

  • Delegation to managers works only with a common shareholder objective: maximise wealth, i.e. current stock price.
  • Value-adding projects raise shareholder wealth.
  • Wealth is a stock variable; profit is a flow variable.
  • Cutting R&D or training boosts current profit but hurts long-term profit.

Evaluating Investment Decisions

Decision rule and opportunity cost

Setup: the firm has a project and enough cash to fund it. The goal is to maximise current share value. The financial manager must choose: invest the cash in the project or pay it out as dividend so shareholders can invest for themselves in the financial market.

Rule: invest in the project as long as R1>R2R_1 > R_2.

Opportunity cost of capital and project risk

The opportunity cost of investing in the project is not R1R_1 but R2R_2: shareholders forego the chance to earn R2R_2 on their own.

Opportunity cost of capital for a project = the expected return in the financial market on assets of the same risk as the project.

  • Riskier assets are expected to give higher returns (stocks are expected to return more than bonds). So the greater the project's risk, the higher its opportunity cost of capital.
  • Completely safe project: look at the safest market asset, government bonds (the government is the last to default, and can print money to service obligations). The government bond interest rate is the opportunity cost.
  • Risky project: use the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM), covered in later modules. Intuition:

Opportunity cost=Risk-free rate+Risk premium\text{Opportunity cost} = \text{Risk-free rate} + \text{Risk premium}

The risk premium depends on risk, represented by beta. Higher beta means a larger premium and a higher opportunity cost. If the project is riskless, the premium is zero and the opportunity cost equals the risk-free rate (the government bond rate).

Key takeaways

  • Choice: reinvest the cash in the project or return it as dividends.
  • Invest only if the project's return exceeds the same-risk market return.
  • Opportunity cost of capital depends on project risk; higher risk means higher cost.
  • Safe project: risk-free rate (government bonds). Risky project: risk-free rate plus a beta-based risk premium (CAPM).

Agency Costs

Agency relationship and agency problem

An agency relationship exists when one party hires another to represent their interests. The hirer is the principal; the hired is the agent. Shareholders (principals) and managers (agents) form such a relationship.

The principal-agent (agency) problem is the possible conflict of interest between them: what is good for the principal may not be good for the agent.

Illustration. A company has a value-adding but risky project. Ideally managers accept it, raising shareholder wealth. In practice they may reject it, because if it fails they may be fired, and managers worry about their jobs more than shareholder interests.

Agency costs

Agency costs are the costs of these conflicts of interest between shareholders and managers.

Form of agency cost Example
Unnecessary perks paid by the company A luxurious, unneeded corporate jet
Fraud / extreme self-dealing At Tyco International (early 2000s), the CEO spent $2 million on his wife's birthday bash and charged half ($1 million) to the company
Monitoring expenses Paying auditors to check the accuracy of financial statements
Cost of lost opportunity Managers shy away from a value-adding but risky project, so shareholders lose a valuable opportunity

Mitigating agency problems and corporate governance

Mitigating agency problems
  • Align interests
    • Give managers shares
    • Employee stock options
  • Monitor
    • Board of directors supervision
    • Auditors
  • Punish
    • Replace managers
    • Market discipline: hostile takeover
    • Legal penalty: insider trading ban
  • Align objectives: give managers shares (they become shareholders) or employee stock options (value rises with the stock price, so managers try to maximise it).
  • Monitor: supervision by the board of directors and auditors; some of this is mandatory by law.
  • Punish: managers can be replaced if they do not pursue shareholder goals. The market disciplines too: companies whose managers are not maximising value become attractive targets of a hostile takeover (a takeover against the wishes of management). The law punishes misuse of private information; trading on unpublished price-sensitive information is insider trading, prohibited by law.

Together these mechanisms form part of a good corporate governance system.

Key takeaways

  • Shareholders are principals; managers are agents; conflicts of interest create the agency problem.
  • Agency costs include perks, fraud, monitoring expenses and lost opportunities.
  • Remedies: align (shares, stock options), monitor (board, auditors), punish (replacement, hostile takeover, insider-trading law).
  • These mechanisms constitute corporate governance.
Revise before your examAll 4 exam tips from this module in one list
  1. A public limited company is identified by a name ending only in "Limited"; it need not be listed on a stock exchange. The decisive private/public difference is share transferability, not the share counts.
  2. Wealth = stock variable (balance sheet, a date); profit = flow variable (income statement, a period). Short-term profit can be inflated by cutting R&D and training, harming long-term value.
  3. The opportunity cost of a project is the market return R2R_2 at the project's own risk level, not the project's return R1R_1. Accept only if R1>R2R_1 > R_2.
  4. Monitoring costs (e.g. audit fees) and lost opportunities count as agency costs, not just visible perks and fraud.

Test yourself on this module

Questions from these notes, one at a time, with feedback. Your weak topics are saved.

Set it up free Takes about a minute. Free plans work.