Module Overview
The opportunity cost of capital for a project depends on the project's risk, but until now neither the measure of risk nor the exact risk-return link was defined. This module builds that chain: security and portfolio risk, then diversification, then the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM), then cost of equity, cost of debt and the weighted average cost of capital (WACC).
- 1Risk as variability of return
- 2Portfolio risk and diversification
- 3Specific vs market risk
- 4Beta measures market risk
- 5CAPM and SML
- 6Cost of equity, debt and assets
- 7Project discount rate
Introduction to Risk
Risk is variability in something you care about. Here the variable is return, so risk means variability of returns. The two standard measures are variance and standard deviation.
- Divide by because variance is estimated from a sample of observations.
- Standard deviation is the positive square root of variance, so it can never be negative.
- It is measured in the same units as the variable (variance is in squared units).
Worked example: four years of returns
Annual returns: 15%, 9%, 6%, 12%.
- Mean: .
- Deviations from the mean: for year 1 (15 - 10.5), and similarly for the other three years.
- Square the deviations and sum: .
- Variance: .
- Standard deviation: .
Key takeaways
- Risk = variability of return, measured by variance or standard deviation.
- Sample variance divides by ; standard deviation is never negative and has the variable's units.
Risk and Return: the Historical Evidence
Compare three portfolios of US securities.
- Treasury bills (T-bills): US government, mature in under a year. No default risk, and short maturity keeps prices stable.
- Treasury bonds (T-bonds): US government, maturity 1 to 10 years. No default risk, but long-term bond prices are more sensitive to interest rates (rates up, prices down, and vice versa). They carry interest rate risk.
- Common stocks: prices move with the fortunes of the issuing companies, so intuition says greatest risk.
Data from 1900 to 2023 confirm the intuition:
| Portfolio | Average annual standard deviation | Average annual return | Risk premium over T-bills |
|---|---|---|---|
| T-bills | 2.7% | 3.4% | 0 |
| T-bonds | 9.3% | 5.0% | |
| Common stocks | 19.6% | 11.5% |
T-bills were least variable, stocks most variable, bonds in the middle, and returns rose in the same order. By bearing risk, investors earned a risk premium. T-bills are the safest asset, so they are treated as the risk-free asset, and the risk-free rate is the return on T-bills.
Key takeaways
- Higher risk went with higher average return across bills, bonds and stocks.
- Risk premium = return on the security minus the risk-free rate (T-bill return).
Security Risk and Return
Describe a security by its possible states of nature, the probability of each, and its return in each state. States are mutually exclusive (only one occurs) and exhaustive (one must occur), so probabilities sum to 1.
| State | Probability | Return on A | Return on B |
|---|---|---|---|
| Boom | 0.25 | 28% | 10% |
| Normal | 0.50 | 15% | 13% |
| Recession | 0.25 | 10% |
Security A
Security B
(The lecture states in later steps.)
Key takeaways
- Expected return is the probability-weighted average of state returns.
- Standard deviation uses probability weights on squared deviations from the expected return.
Portfolio Risk and Return
Form a portfolio with 50% in A and 50% in B. First find the portfolio return in each state:
| State | Probability | Portfolio return |
|---|---|---|
| Boom | 0.25 | |
| Normal | 0.50 | |
| Recession | 0.25 |
Expected return:
This equals the weighted average of the individual expected returns: . Portfolio expected return is always the weighted average of the securities' expected returns.
Risk:
The weighted average of the individual standard deviations is . The portfolio standard deviation (5.45%) is below the weighted average (6.075%). The reason is diversification.
Key takeaways
- Compute portfolio return state by state, then take its expectation, or just weight the expected returns.
- Portfolio is less than the weighted average of the stocks' because of diversification.
Diversification
Covariance and correlation
Covariance shows the direction of the relationship between two variables.
- Positive: the variables move together; negative: they move in opposite directions.
- No bounds: from to .
- Covariance of a variable with itself is its variance: .
Correlation standardizes covariance.
- : perfectly positively correlated; : perfectly negatively correlated.
| Covariance | Correlation | |
|---|---|---|
| Gives direction | Yes | Yes |
| Gives strength | No | Yes |
| Bounds | None | to |
Two-stock portfolio variance
Let stock 1 have weight and standard deviation , and stock 2 weight and . Build a 2 by 2 matrix: the diagonal cells are variance terms (, ), and the two off-diagonal cells are each a covariance term . Summing all four cells:
Since :
Special cases
| Correlation | Result |
|---|---|
| , so : the weighted average. No diversification benefit. | |
| (absolute value, since cannot be negative). If also , then . |
A correlation of exactly is almost impossible in real life, so a zero-risk portfolio does not occur in practice.
Worked example: two-stock portfolio
Invest USD 55 in stock 1 and USD 45 in stock 2. , , , , .
Weights: , .
The portfolio's 17.04% is lower than both stocks' standard deviations (17.1% and 20.8%).
Effect of correlation. The weighted average of the standard deviations is .
| Portfolio | |
|---|---|
| 18.77% (equals the weighted average) | |
| (given) | 17.04% |
| 0.04% (the minimum) |
Portfolio risk falls steadily as correlation falls from to . (The lecture also poses ; they lie between these extremes.)
Adding a third stock
Existing portfolio of stocks 1 and 2 (USD 100): expected return 14.5%, . Invest another USD 100 in stock 3: expected return 25%, , correlation with the existing portfolio . Weights are and .
Return rose from 14.5% to 19.75% while risk fell slightly from 17.04% to 16.95%. This does not always happen, but it is attributable to diversification.
How much diversification?
- Plotting average portfolio standard deviation against number of stocks shows it keeps falling as stocks are added.
- Even a little diversification gives a substantial reduction in variability; most of the benefit comes with relatively few stocks.
- It works because stock prices are not perfectly correlated ().
Key takeaways
- , bounded in ; covariance is unbounded.
- .
- Portfolio equals the weighted average only when ; it falls as falls.
- Portfolio expected return is a weighted average regardless of correlation.
Specific Risk and Market Risk
| Specific risk | Market risk | |
|---|---|---|
| Meaning | Peculiar to a firm or industry | Shared by most businesses; stems from market-wide fluctuations |
| Example | A pilot strike hits aviation, little effect elsewhere | Global financial crisis, COVID-19 (some firms hit more, some less) |
| Diversifiable? | Yes | No |
| Other names | Diversifiable, unsystematic, unique, idiosyncratic risk | Non-diversifiable, systematic risk |
Adding securities, especially from other industries, steadily reduces specific risk. A reasonably well-diversified portfolio carries essentially no specific risk, only market risk.
Key takeaways
- Total risk splits into diversifiable specific risk and non-diversifiable market risk.
- A well-diversified portfolio is exposed primarily to market risk.
Measuring Market Risk: Beta
Beta is the sensitivity of a security's return to the return on the market portfolio, so it measures market risk. Graphically, regress stock returns (y-axis) on market returns (x-axis); beta is the slope of the fitted line.
- Theoretically the market portfolio is all assets in the economy. In practice a broad index such as the BSE Sensex or NSE Nifty 50 represents it.
Using and cancelling one :
Benchmark betas
- Market: (covariance of a variable with itself is its variance).
- Risk-free asset (for example a T-bill): its return does not change with market conditions, so and .
Reading beta
| Beta | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| As much market risk as the market | Market portfolio | |
| More market risk than the market | Luxury goods firm such as BMW: sales and earnings surge in booms and take a big hit in downturns, so a 1% market move brings a move of more than 1% | |
| Less market risk than the market | Necessity goods (for example FMCG): people keep buying whatever the economy does | |
| Moves against the market | Counter-cyclical firm, for example an insolvency/restructuring firm that does well in downturns |
Portfolio beta
Portfolio beta is the weighted average of the betas of its securities. A well-diversified portfolio carries no specific risk, and its risk is proportional to its beta.
Key takeaways
- ; it is the slope of the stock-on-market regression.
- , .
- Cyclical, discretionary firms have high beta; necessity firms have beta below 1; counter-cyclical firms can have negative beta.
- Portfolio beta = weighted average of betas.
The Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM)
A security's risk premium is its expected return minus the T-bill return. For a well-diversified portfolio the right risk measure is beta. Two anchor points are known:
| Asset | Beta | Risk premium |
|---|---|---|
| Risk-free (T-bill) | 0 | |
| Market | 1 |
For betas between 0 and 1, or any other value, CAPM (Sharpe, Lintner and Treynor) says the risk premium varies in direct proportion to beta:
is the market risk premium. CAPM gives the expected (required) return on a security, so it gives the opportunity cost of capital for a project or investment: the higher the project's beta, the higher the return required.
Security Market Line (SML)
The SML plots expected return (y-axis) against beta (x-axis). It passes through the risk-free point and the market point .
- Slope ; intercept .
- Line equation: , which is exactly CAPM. The SML is the graph of CAPM.
Key takeaways
- ; risk premium is proportional to beta.
- SML: intercept , slope .
- CAPM gives a project's opportunity cost of capital from its beta.
Asset and Project Cost of Capital
Asset cost of capital
A firm is a collection of assets (A), financed by debt (D) and equity (E). The asset cost of capital is:
- the opportunity cost of capital for investing in all the firm's assets, and equivalently
- the expected return on a portfolio of all the firm's debt and equity.
For an all-equity firm (the lecture's example is Infosys) it equals the expected return on the firm's stock. It is also called the company cost of capital or simply the cost of capital. It is the right discount rate for the firm's average-risk projects, such as expansion of the existing business. It is not appropriate for projects riskier or safer than the existing business.
Project cost of capital and the SML rule
Project risk is measured by the project's beta. Higher beta means higher required return (higher opportunity cost). Compare the project's actual return with the SML's required return at its beta.
| Project position | Meaning | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| Above SML | Return greater than required for its risk, so NPV | Accept |
| Below SML | Return less than required for its risk, so NPV | Reject |
Why the asset cost of capital rule fails
The asset cost of capital rule accepts any project whose return exceeds the firm's asset cost of capital , regardless of risk. It causes two errors:
- A project below the SML but above (a negative NPV project) is accepted.
- A project above the SML but with return below (a positive NPV project) is rejected.
So many negative NPV projects get accepted and many positive NPV projects get rejected. The appropriate discount rate depends on the risk of the project, not on the company undertaking it.
Then why estimate the asset cost of capital?
- Many projects are expansions of the existing business, which are average-risk, so is exactly right.
- Managers have good intuition about relative risk but not absolute risk. It is easier to add a markup to (or subtract from) for a riskier (or safer) project than to estimate a project's cost of capital from scratch.
Key takeaways
- is the return on all debt and equity, and is right only for average-risk projects.
- Accept projects above the SML, reject those below.
- The asset cost of capital rule accepts negative NPV and rejects positive NPV projects.
- is still a useful starting point because managers judge relative risk better than absolute risk.
Debt, Equity and Asset Cost of Capital
Viewing the firm as a portfolio, the market-value balance sheet has assets on one side and debt and equity on the other. The asset cost of capital is the weighted average of the cost of debt () and cost of equity ():
- Weights use market values, not book values.
- = market value of equity = shares outstanding price per share, also called market capitalization.
- = market value of debt. In practice this is not very different from book value, so book value of debt is used as a proxy. Book value of equity is generally not a good proxy for its market value.
Which is riskiest?
A multi-step income statement shows why debt is safer:
- 1Salesminus COGS
- 2Gross profitminus operating expenses
- 3EBITminus interest, paid to bondholders
- 4EBTminus taxes
- 5PATdividends to shareholders, remainder retained
- 6Reinvested
Interest is paid first, and dividends only from what is left. Equity is a residual claim on the cash flows of the assets, standing behind debt. So debt is safer than equity, which gives and . Since is a weighted average of the two:
Estimating Cost of Equity and Cost of Debt
Apply CAPM to each claim (market risk premium ):
- Beta of equity: regress stock returns on market returns; the slope is .
- Beta of debt: if the debt is traded, regress bond returns on market returns in the same way.
- Alternative for when debt is not traded (so is unknown): add a spread to the risk-free rate. The spread depends on the riskiness of the debt, that is, the firm's credit rating: the higher the rating, the lower the spread.
- Because assets are the weighted average of debt and equity, is the weighted average of and .
On the SML: risk-free at beta 0 with return ; debt slightly above at ; assets in between; equity far higher at .
Key takeaways
- with market-value weights.
- Cost of equity from CAPM; cost of debt from CAPM or plus a credit-rating-based spread.
- because .
Risk and Beta Practice
Three stocks; stock 1 has and (the lowest of the three in both), stock 2 has , stock 3 has .
(a) Safest for a diversified investor? A diversified investor holds only market risk, so the relevant measure is beta. The lowest beta is stock 1 (). Corporate finance assumes investors are diversified, so beta is the risk measure that matters.
(b) Safest for an undiversified investor holding one stock? Total risk matters, so use standard deviation. The lowest is stock 1 ().
(c) Beta of an equally weighted portfolio. Weight each:
Asset Cost of Capital: Practice
Fictitious Corporation: book balance sheet 50% debt, 50% equity. Debt trades near book value at a 4% interest rate. Market cap of equity is double its book value. , , market risk premium . Find .
Step 1: market values. Let total book assets . Book debt and book equity . Debt trades at book, so . Equity market value is double book, so .
Step 2: cost of equity (CAPM).
Step 3: weights and .
Cost of Capital and Project Discount Rate
Firm with market value of equity of Rs. 60 million and debt of Rs. 40 million. , market risk premium , . Debt is risk-free () and there are no taxes.
(a) Required return on the stock (CAPM):
(b) Asset cost of capital. First , the risk-free rate.
(c) Discount rate for an expansion of the present business. Project discount rate depends on project risk. An expansion has the same risk as the firm's assets, so the appropriate rate is the asset cost of capital, 11.4%.
Key takeaways
- Get from CAPM, from CAPM (risk-free debt: ), then weight by market values to get .
- Use as the discount rate only for projects with the same risk as the existing business.
Revise before your examAll 7 exam tips from this module in one list
- Returns average linearly across securities, but standard deviations do not. Portfolio return = weighted average; portfolio risk weighted average of risks, with equality only at perfect positive correlation.
- Both capture only linear relationships, not nonlinear ones.
- Diversification removes specific risk only. Market risk stays.
- Never use the company's cost of capital for a project of different risk. The SML, not the firm's own , is the benchmark.
- Debt has the lowest return and equity the highest, with the asset cost of capital in between. The ordering of betas matches.
- Diversified investor: look at beta. Undiversified investor: look at standard deviation.
- Use market value weights. Here equity is two thirds of firm value, not one half as the book balance sheet suggests.
Test yourself on this module
Questions from these notes, one at a time, with feedback. Your weak topics are saved.