Term 7 · Module 7 of 9

Corporate Payout Decisions

Corporate Finance

Practise this module in Claude, ChatGPT or Gemini

Set it up free
Mind map

Payout Policy: What a Firm Does with Free Cash Flow

Every period a firm generates free cash flow (FCF): operating cash flow after subtracting the investment needed for growth. FCF can be positive or negative. When it is positive, the firm can retain it, pay it out, or do part of each.

  • Retaininvest in projects (positive, zero or negative NPV), retire debt, or build up cash reserves.
  • Pay out to shareholdersthrough a cash dividend or a share repurchase (buyback), where the firm buys shares from existing shareholders and gives them cash.

Example: in July 2019 Infosys raised the share of free cash flow it returns to shareholders from up to 70% to 85%, effective FY 2019-20.

A third form of payout involves no cash: the stock dividend (shares given instead of cash), closely related to stock splits and reverse splits.

Key takeaways

  • FCF is cash after growth investment; positive FCF is retained, paid out, or split.
  • Payout routes: cash dividends and buybacks (cash), stock dividends (no cash).
  • Retained cash is not automatically well used: it can go into negative-NPV projects.

Cash Dividends

The board of directors decides whether to pay a dividend. Once declared, it becomes a liability of the firm. In India, a dividend proposed by the board becomes a liability once approved by shareholders.

Cash Dividends

Three ways to express a dividend

Measure Formula
Dividend per share (DPS) Amount paid per share
Dividend payout DPSEPS\dfrac{\text{DPS}}{\text{EPS}}
Dividend yield DPSPrice per share\dfrac{\text{DPS}}{\text{Price per share}}

Dividend timeline

Date Meaning
Declaration (announcement) date Board authorises the dividend.
Ex-dividend date On or after this date, a buyer of the share is not entitled to the dividend. Before it, the stock trades cum-dividend (buyer gets the dividend).
Record date Only shareholders of record on this date receive the dividend.
Payment date Dividend is actually paid.
  1. 1Declaration date
  2. 2Ex-dividend date
  3. 3Record date
  4. 4Payment date

Example (ONGC): regular dividend of Rs. 1.25 per share declared on 21 May 2025; ex-dividend date and record date both 4 September 2025; paid on 27 September 2025.

Why the price falls on the ex-dividend date. A cash dividend shrinks the firm: market value falls, ideally by the dividend paid. A share is fractional ownership of the assets, so the share price falls ideally by the dividend per share.

Limits on dividend choice

A firm cannot declare any dividend it likes:

  • Lenders may restrict dividends so enough cash remains to service loans.
  • Some countries have creditor-protection laws against excessive dividends.
  • In some countries (e.g. Brazil, Chile) law forces a minimum payout of earnings.

Key takeaways

  • Declared dividend = liability; payout = DPS/EPS; yield = DPS/price.
  • Order of dates: declaration, ex-dividend, record, payment.
  • Buy before the ex-dividend date (cum-dividend) to receive the dividend.
  • Ex-dividend price drops ideally by the dividend per share.
  • Lenders, creditor laws and minimum-payout laws constrain dividends.

Share Repurchases

A share repurchase (buyback) returns cash by buying back shares. Four methods:

Method How it works
Open market repurchase Firm announces intent and buys in the secondary market like any investor, over several months.
Tender offer Offer to buy a stated number of shares at a fixed price within a short window (about 10 days). Price usually at a substantial premium of roughly 10% to 20% over market. If too few shares are tendered, the offer can be cancelled and no buyback occurs.
Dutch auction Firm sets a price range; shareholders say how many shares they will sell at each price; the firm pays the lowest price at which it can buy the desired number.
Targeted repurchase Firm negotiates directly with a major shareholder.

Open market repurchases and tender offers are the two most commonly used routes in India.

Key takeaways

  • Four routes: open market, tender offer, Dutch auction, targeted.
  • Tender offers carry a premium (about 10-20%) and a short window.
  • In India, open market and tender offer dominate.

Stock Dividends, Splits and Reverse Splits

Stock dividend (bonus shares)

A stock dividend (called bonus shares in India) gives each shareholder additional shares, with no cash paid. A 25% stock dividend (1-for-4) gives 1 new share per 4 held. LIC announced in April 2026 its first 1-for-1 bonus issue (100% stock dividend): 1 extra share per share held.

Effects: cash and total market value of equity are unchanged; shares outstanding rise; so price per share falls, because the same equity value is spread over more shares.

Worked example: 50% (1-for-2) stock dividend

Firm: Rs. 20 million excess cash, no debt, 10 million shares, other assets worth Rs. 400 million.

MV of firm=20+400=420 (Rs. million),Pbefore=42010=Rs. 42\text{MV of firm} = 20 + 400 = 420 \text{ (Rs. million)}, \qquad P_{\text{before}} = \frac{420}{10} = \text{Rs. } 42

New shares =10/2=5= 10/2 = 5 million, so shares outstanding =15= 15 million. Value is still 420 million:

Pafter=42015=Rs. 28P_{\text{after}} = \frac{420}{15} = \text{Rs. } 28

Shares up, price down, total value intact.

Stock split

In a stock split shareholders receive additional shares; in a 2-for-1 split, 1 old share becomes 2 new ones.

  • Whymake the stock more affordable and attractive to small investors, raising demand and liquidity, which may lift the price. Example: NVIDIA's price passed USD 1,000 in 2024, and it split 10-for-1.
  • Evidencesplit announcements are associated, on average, with about a 2% price increase (easier for retail investors to trade, so more liquidity and demand).

Reverse split

A reverse split consolidates shares into fewer, higher-priced shares; in a 1-for-10 reverse split, every 10 shares become 1.

  • Why: to avoid delisting (NYSE and NASDAQ require a minimum price of USD 1; Indian exchanges have no such requirement), and to improve marketability, since a higher price attracts investors who avoid penny stocks.

Splits and reverse splits keep prices in a typical range: most NYSE firms trade at USD 10-60; most Nifty 500 firms at Rs. 100-1,500.

Key takeaways

  • Stock dividend: no cash, more shares, lower price, unchanged equity value.
  • Worked case: Rs. 42 with 10 million shares becomes Rs. 28 with 15 million.
  • Split: more shares, lower price, about +2% announcement effect.
  • Reverse split: fewer shares, higher price; used to avoid delisting and improve marketability.

Comparing Payouts and Corporate Actions

Action Cash Market value of equity Shares outstanding Price per share
Cash dividend Down Down No change Down
Share repurchase (at market price) Down Down Down No change
Stock dividend (bonus) No change No change Up Down
Stock split No change No change Up Down
Reverse split No change No change Down Up

Key takeaways

  • Only cash dividends and buybacks reduce cash and equity value.
  • Buyback cuts shares; dividend cuts price.
  • Stock dividend and split behave alike; reverse split is their mirror image.

Information Content of Payout Decisions

Dividends as signals

Managers hold private information and use announcements to signal it. Observed behaviour:

  • Managers are reluctant to make dividend changes that may have to be reversed.
  • Managers smooth dividends: changes follow shifts in long-run sustainable earnings, not transitory ones. General Motors changed its regular dividend only eight times in 23 years (1985-2008) while earnings varied widely.
  • Changes matter more than levels. A dividend of Rs. 5 is a major decision if last year's was Rs. 4, but no big deal if last year's was also Rs. 5.

Dividend increases are generally good news: managers raise dividends only when confident they can be maintained, so an increase signals confidence in future earnings and can predict them.

But not always. An increase may signal a lack of positive-NPV projects. Microsoft initiated dividends in 2003, largely read as declining growth prospects rather than higher future profitability. Dividends must be read in the context of the kind of new information managers are likely to have.

Empirical evidence: dividend increases lead on average to about +0.5% in the stock price, dividend decreases to about -2%: an asymmetric reaction. Sensitivity to dividend changes has declined over time.

Share repurchases as signals

  • Managers are much less committed to buybacks than to dividends; an announcement does not commit them to repurchase in later years.
  • Unlike dividends, buybacks are not smoothed across years.
  • Buybacks often signal that shares are undervalued. When a firm offers a premium, senior managers and directors typically commit to hold their shares, so a premium repurchase announcement draws a positive price reaction.
Feature Dividends Repurchases
Commitment High Low
Smoothing Yes No
Typical signal Confidence in sustainable earnings (or lack of projects) Undervaluation

Key takeaways

  • Dividends are smoothed and sticky; changes, not levels, carry information.
  • Increase = confidence, but may also mean fewer good projects (Microsoft).
  • Evidence is asymmetric: about +0.5% for increases, about -2% for cuts.
  • Buybacks are flexible, unsmoothed signals of undervaluation.

Payout Policy in Perfect Capital Markets

Assume perfect capital markets (no taxes, transaction costs or other imperfections).

Payout Policy in Perfect Capital Markets

Dividend versus repurchase: worked example

Firm: Rs. 20 million excess cash, no debt, 10 million shares, other assets Rs. 400 million. Current price: 420/10=Rs. 42420/10 = \text{Rs. } 42. The board will pay out the Rs. 20 million either as (1) a cash dividend or (2) a repurchase at the market price.

Policy 1: cash dividend of Rs. 20 million. Cash becomes 0, firm value =0+400=400=0+400=400, shares stay at 10 million:

Pex=40010=Rs. 40,DPS=2010=Rs. 2P_{\text{ex}} = \frac{400}{10} = \text{Rs. } 40, \qquad \text{DPS} = \frac{20}{10} = \text{Rs. } 2

Pex-div=Pcum-div−DPS=42−2=40P_{\text{ex-div}} = P_{\text{cum-div}} - \text{DPS} = 42 - 2 = 40

In perfect markets the price drops by the dividend per share at the ex-dividend date.

Policy 2: repurchase of Rs. 20 million at Rs. 42.

Shares repurchased=2042≈0.476 million,Shares left=10−0.476=9.524 million\text{Shares repurchased} = \frac{20}{42} \approx 0.476 \text{ million}, \qquad \text{Shares left} = 10 - 0.476 = 9.524 \text{ million}

P=4009.524≈Rs. 42P = \frac{400}{9.524} \approx \text{Rs. } 42

In perfect markets an open market repurchase has no effect on the share price.

Homemade dividends

Consider an investor holding 2,000 shares and no cash (value 2,000×42=Rs. 84,0002{,}000 \times 42 = \text{Rs. } 84{,}000), who does not participate in the buyback.

Case Shares value Cash Total
Before payout 2000×42=84,0002000\times42 = 84{,}000 0 84,000
After dividend 2000×40=80,0002000\times40 = 80{,}000 2000×2=4,0002000\times2=4{,}000 84,000
After buyback (no participation) 2000×42=84,0002000\times42 = 84{,}000 0 84,000

Total wealth is the same; the investor may still prefer one form, depending on cash needs. Either can be replicated:

  • Firm buys back, investor wants cashsell shares. For Rs. 4,000: 4000/42≈954000/42 \approx 95 shares sold, leaving about 1,905 shares worth about Rs. 80,000 plus about Rs. 4,000 cash, total still Rs. 84,000. This is a homemade dividend.
  • Firm pays dividend, investor wants sharesreinvest at the ex-dividend price. 4000/40=1004000/40 = 100 shares bought, giving 2,100 shares worth 2100×40=Rs. 84,0002100\times40 = \text{Rs. } 84{,}000, no cash.

Larger homemade dividend

The firm pays Rs. 2 per share; the investor wants Rs. 9,000 in total (Rs. 4.50 per share on 2,000 shares).

  • Dividend received: 2000×2=4,0002000\times2 = 4{,}000.
  • Extra cash needed: 9000−4000=5,0009000-4000 = 5{,}000.
  • Shares to sell at the ex-dividend price: 5000/40=1255000/40 = 125.
  • Holdings: 2000−125=1,8752000-125 = 1{,}875 shares worth 1875×40=Rs. 75,0001875\times40 = \text{Rs. } 75{,}000, plus Rs. 9,000 cash, total Rs. 84,000.

Payout policy irrelevance

Miller-Modigliani payout policy irrelevance: in perfect capital markets, payout policy does not matter. Whether the firm pays dividends, repurchases shares, or does nothing, investors can replicate the other outcomes on their own.

Key takeaways

  • Dividend: price falls by DPS. Market-price buyback: price unchanged.
  • Investors are indifferent: they can sell shares or reinvest dividends to replicate either.
  • Homemade dividends underpin Miller-Modigliani irrelevance.

Why Payout Policy Matters: Market Imperfections

In practice some firms pay dividends, others use only buybacks, some hoard cash and others pay it out. Imperfections explain this: taxes, agency costs, firm life cycle, and behavioural factors.

Why Payout Policy Matters: Market Imperfections

Taxes

Interest on debt is tax-deductible, but interest earned on surplus cash is taxed. So debt has a tax advantage, and holding cash has a tax disadvantage: cash is equivalent to negative debt. Corporate taxes make retaining excess cash costly.

Worked example

A firm pays 35% corporate tax on interest from 1-year T-bills yielding 6%. An investor who pays no taxes compares (1) a Rs. 100 dividend now versus (2) retaining the cash for a year and then paying a dividend.

  • Choice 1investor invests Rs. 100 herself: 100×1.06=Rs. 106100\times1.06 = \text{Rs. } 106 (no tax).
  • Choice 2firm earns an after-tax return

6%×(1−0.35)=3.90%,100×1.039=Rs. 103.906\% \times (1-0.35) = 3.90\%, \qquad 100\times1.039 = \text{Rs. } 103.90

Since 106>103.90106 > 103.90, the investor prefers the dividend now. If dividends and repurchases are taxed differently, investors prefer the lower-taxed form.

Agency costs of idle cash

With excess cash, managers may continue money-losing pet projects, pay excessive perks, or make negative-NPV acquisitions. Paying out excess cash (dividends or buybacks) can therefore raise the share price of such firms, since investors fear the cash would be wasted.

Firm life cycle

Stage Payout implication
Young, growing Many profitable projects, so retain and reinvest FCF. Retention avoids issuance costs (about 1-3% for debt, 3.5-7% for equity) and minimises shareholders' immediate tax bill. Investors do not fear overinvestment since FCF goes into positive-NPV projects.
Mature Positive-NPV projects become scarcer relative to cash flow; cash accumulates and investors worry about overinvestment and perks, favouring payouts.

Behavioural explanations

  • Dividend clienteles: some investors (e.g. retirees) prefer regular, stable cash dividends. Homemade dividends are possible in theory, but regular dividends save transaction costs and inconvenience, so these investors may pay more for dividend-paying shares than for buyback firms.
  • Bird-in-the-hand theory: "a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush"; dividend payers may enjoy higher prices. Rational theories cannot explain this. Evidence: Frontier Communications had two share classes with identical fundamentals, one paying cash dividends (lower value) and one stock dividends (higher value), yet the cash-dividend class traded at a higher price. The premium varied over time, so preferences for cash dividends change.
  • Industry herding: firms copy competitors' dividend policies, out of fear of being left alone (FOMO).

Key takeaways

  • Taxes: cash is negative debt; retaining cash is costly, so the investor prefers payout now (Rs. 106 versus Rs. 103.90).
  • Agency costs: paying out idle cash lifts price by curbing wasteful spending.
  • Young firms retain (issuance costs, positive-NPV projects); mature firms pay out.
  • Behavioural: clienteles, bird in the hand, herding.
Revise before your examAll 2 exam tips from this module in one list
  1. A buyback at market price leaves the share price unchanged (shares fall in proportion to value); a cash dividend cuts the price; stock dividends and splits only re-slice the same value.
  2. Use the ex-dividend price when reinvesting a dividend and the current price when selling shares in a buyback case. Total investor wealth never changes.

Test yourself on this module

Questions from these notes, one at a time, with feedback. Your weak topics are saved.

Set it up free Takes about a minute. Free plans work.