Term 4 · Module 7 of 9

Customer Insights & Co-creation

Digital Marketing Strategy

Practise this module in Claude, ChatGPT or Gemini

Set it up free
Mind map

Customer Insights & Engagement

Customer insights are systematic understandings of customers, competitors, and the market that drive marketing strategy. Co-creation uses those insights to develop new products, services, or improve existing ones. The module covers how insights are collected, how they enable engagement, and how they fuel market development (a growth path distinct from product development).

Value Delivery Process – Revisited

Market insights underpin every stage of the four-stage value delivery process:

  1. Choose value – Segmentation, targeting, positioning (STP). Requires understanding customer needs, competitor offerings, and gaps.
  2. Provide value – Product/service development, pricing, distribution. Constant monitoring of market changes (competitor moves, evolving preferences).
  3. Communicate value – Marketing communication (6Ms framework). Needs insights into message effectiveness.
  4. Sustain value – Innovation and brand equity management. Insights prevent value erosion and guide improvement.

All marketing mix decisions (4Ps for goods, 7Ps for services) rely on ongoing marketplace insights. Customer satisfaction, value equity, brand equity, and relationship equity are all measured against external data.

Customer Engagement Marketing → Firm Performance

A framework with four building blocks:

Customer Engagement Marketing – a firm’s deliberate efforts to motivate, empower, and measure a customer’s voluntary contribution to marketing functions beyond the core economic transaction (i.e., beyond just buying). Examples: watching/sharing content, giving improvement ideas.

  • This leads to Customer Engagement – voluntary resource contribution (time, effort, ideas) from the customer.

Firm Performance – the ultimate outcome, measured as increased revenues or reduced costs.

Moderator: Customer Owned Resources – the translation of engagement into firm performance depends on the customer’s own assets:

  • Network assetssize and strength of the customer’s personal network.
  • Persuasion capitalability to influence others.
  • Knowledge storesexpertise about the product/brand/category.
  • Creativitycapacity to generate novel content (e.g., user-generated content).

Key takeaways

  • Customer engagement marketing goes beyond transactions to motivate voluntary customer contributions.
  • Customer engagement (voluntary resource input) mediates the link to firm performance.
  • Customer owned resources (network, persuasion, knowledge, creativity) moderate how strongly engagement translates into revenue gains or cost savings.

Drivers of Customer Engagement

A second framework explains when customers engage. Two broad tenets:

Tenet 1: Antecedents of Engagement

Component Description
Product Experience Positive experience with the product/service
Brand Associations Favorable perceptions of the brand
Customer Engagement Marketing (firm-initiated) Two types: Task-based (e.g., asked to write a review, share feedback) and Experiential (e.g., join a ride event, participate in a brand community)

Tenet 2: Psychological Mechanisms

Mechanism Triggered by Effect
Psychological Ownership Good product experience + task-based engagement Customer feels a sense of ownership toward the brand, increasing likelihood of participation
Self-Transformation Experiential engagement initiative Customer undergoes personal change or identity reinforcement, deepening engagement

Causal flow:

Key takeaways

  • Positive product experience and brand associations are prerequisites for customer engagement.
  • Task-based engagement fosters psychological ownership; experiential engagement fosters self-transformation.
  • Both mechanisms increase the likelihood that customers will voluntarily contribute to the firm’s marketing function.

Analytical Models: Customer Transactions

Models are grouped by the customer journey stage:

Stage Data Types Methods
Acquisition RFM (Recency, Frequency, Monetary value), demographics, campaign response, clickstream data RFM scoring, CHAID, linear/logit/probit regression, neural networks, Pareto/NBD, individual-level probability models
Development Cross-sectional & longitudinal data (contractual or non-contractual settings) Probability models (HMM, Markov decision process), parametric models (regression, discrete choice), neural networks, VAR
Retention Satisfaction surveys, loyalty program data, time series Parametric models (churn dependence models), dynamic churn models (HMM, time-varying coefficient, dynamic linear models)
  • Contractual settingCustomer has a subscription or contract (e.g., Amazon Prime, Netflix, B2B software contract).
  • Non-contractual settingPurely transactional (e.g., retail store visits, restaurant).

Analytical Models: Customer Engagement

For engagement (beyond transactions), models use different data:

Engagement Stage Data Methods
Acquisition Play stream data, word-of-mouth data Zero-inflated Poisson, truncated NBD
Development Brand community data, information website data, WOM SEM, regression, agent-based models, VAR
Retention Loyalty program data, social network data, time series Dependence models, dynamic churn (HMM, time-varying coefficient)

Key takeaways

  • Transaction-based models span acquisition, development, and retention; engagement models add a parallel track.
  • RFM data is a classic foundation; digital context adds clickstream, WOM, and social network data.
  • Models range from simple scoring (RFM) to advanced probabilistic methods (HMM, MDP, VAR).

Customer Engagement Value (CEV)

Customer Engagement Value (CEV) is the total monetary value a customer provides to a firm beyond just purchases. It captures four distinct contributions: transactions, referrals, social influence, and knowledge feedback. Intuitively, a customer who only buys is valuable, but one who brings in new buyers, spreads positive word-of-mouth, and helps improve the product is far more valuable.

CEV=f(CLV,CRV,CIV,CKV)\text{CEV} = f(\text{CLV}, \text{CRV}, \text{CIV}, \text{CKV})

The Four Components of CEV

Component Full Name Core Idea Example
CLV Customer Lifetime Value Net present value of all future cash flows from a customer through purchases (transactions, services, cross-buying) over her relationship with the firm. A bike buyer: one-time big purchase + servicing + insurance + loans.
CRV Customer Referral Value Monetary value of paid referrals – existing customers are incentivised to refer others. Reader’s Digest: customers list 16 names → get a joke book.
CIV Customer Influence Value Monetary value of unpaid social influence on other customers/prospects (e.g., social media posts, reviews). A customer posting a video riding a bike; followers consider a test ride.
CKV Customer Knowledge Value Value added through feedback and ideas that improve the product or service. Air fryer user suggests better oil drainage; company modifies the design.

Measuring CEV: Behavioral, Attitudinal, and Network Metrics

Each component is tracked using three lenses:

Component Behavioral Metrics Attitudinal Metrics Network Metrics
CLV Acquisition cost, retention rate, tenure, purchase frequency, cross-buying, spend variance, win-back cost Satisfaction, purchase intention, brand equity, relationship commitment, channel preference, complaint resolution, churn reasons —
CRV CLV of customers acquired through referrals, number of referrals, value of acquired customers, retention of referred customers Likelihood to recommend (e.g., Net Promoter Score), intention to recommend, opinion leadership, tendency to use social media/blogs Number of connections, level of interactions with prospects, tendency to be a hub vs. a weak link across hubs
CIV CLV of customers acquired through influence, number of reviews, product/service expertise, emotional balance of reviews, opinion leadership Tendency to recommend, use of social media/blogs Number of connections, level of interactions with customers (not prospects), hub vs. weak link
CKV CLV of product/service expertise, likelihood of providing feedback Testimonials, reviews (especially in B2B: formal letters), willingness to share insights Number of connections, level of interactions with customers and prospects, hub vs. weak link

Relationships Among CEV Components

The proposed relationships between components use signs to indicate the expected direction of impact:

Row / Column → CRV → CIV → CKV
CLV Positive: good transaction experience → higher referral willingness when incentivised (proposal not detailed) (proposal not detailed)
CRV — (proposal not detailed) (proposal not detailed)
CIV (proposal not detailed) — Positive but depends on product experience and polarised online activity (extremely high/low activity)

Key Takeaways – CEV

  • CEV = CLV + CRV + CIV + CKV.
  • CLV = transaction-based; CRV = paid referrals; CIV = unpaid social influence; CKV = customer feedback.
  • Measure each component through behavior (system data), attitude (surveys/NPS), and network (connections, hub vs. weak link).
  • Weak links connecting different networks can be as valuable as hubs.
  • Relationships between components are positive and synergistic.

Landmark Group: Customer Insights in Practice

Landmark Group (Dubai-based, ~50 years, Indian entrepreneur) operates multiple brands in India as an omnichannel retailer (physical + online). Its brands include:

  • Lifestylelarge-format department store (apparel, footwear, fragrances, cosmetics)
  • Maxvalue fashion (apparel, footwear, accessories)
  • EasyBuyvalue apparel for Tier 2/3 cities
  • Home Centrehome improvement (furniture, kitchen appliances)
  • Spar Hypergrocery hypermarket (licensee of Spar International; also sells apparel, appliances)
  • Fun Cityplay centre for kids aged 4–12
  • Krispy Krememaster franchisee in South & West India (doughnuts)

Online presence: own sites (lifestylestores.com, maxfashions.in, homecentre.in, sparonline) + third-party platforms (Myntra, Amazon, Flipkart).

Data Collection via Apps

To gather behavioural and attitudinal insights, Landmark launched two apps for different brands:

App Brand Features
Max Buddy Max Unlock offers, find missing sizes, self-checkout, Elite membership benefits
Spar Genie Spar Offers, coupons, wallet, list, Landmark Rewards (group-wide loyalty programme)

Strategy: Encourage customers to share data through delightful engagement, shopping incentives, and a simple loyalty programme. Initially, no loyalty programme existed – customers simply shared their phone number at billing. Because most Indians have a unique mobile number, this served as the unique identifier to create a single view of the customer. Later, SMS/email offers were sent, and apps were introduced to capture richer usage data.

Customer insights are the foundation for co-creation – feedback from CKV (e.g., product suggestions, feature requests) feeds into innovation and improvements, while influence (CIV) and referrals (CRV) drive acquisition. Landmark’s omnichannel data allows it to understand customer behaviour across touchpoints and tailor engagement.

Key Takeaways – Landmark Group

  • Unique identifier (phone number) enables a single customer view across brands.
  • Data collection is incentivised through loyalty programmes, app benefits, and personalised offers.
  • Behavioural (purchase history, app usage) and attitudinal (feedback, reviews) data are integrated.
  • Insights drive co-creation: customer knowledge (CKV) directly improves products and services.

Customer Data

Organizations need a unique identifier to create a single view of the customer. At Landmark, this begins with a simple mobile number. Customers are motivated to share data when they receive delightful experiences or incentives.

Types of Customer Data

Data Type Description Sources / Examples
Demographic data Markers such as age, income, education, language, geography Surveys, inferred from purchases
Contact data Email ID, phone number, delivery address Online/offline purchases, loyalty sign‑up
Transaction data Buying behavior: what, when, how many, how much, brands POS systems (offline + online)
Browsing & shopping journey data Online behavior, page visits, cart actions Digital properties (website, app)
Response data Customer reaction to company‑initiated comms (SMS, WhatsApp offers) Click‑through, purchase after promotion
Feedback data Reviews, contact‑center notes, survey responses App, in‑person, online forms
Complaints data Returns, service issues, resolution history Contact center, email, app
Social media listening Brand mentions, sentiment, user‑generated content (images, videos) Social networks, review platforms
Alliance / partnership data Data from co‑branded programs (e.g., Louis Philippe, Van Heusen) Shared CRM, joint promotions
Third‑party enrichment Data from credit card companies, telecoms, other partners with similar targets Data partnerships

Data Quality

Volume of data is increasing and now includes images, videos, and other formats. Quality (currency, relevance, cleanliness) is an ongoing challenge.

Three Key Questions: Who, What, Why

Data helps answer three core questions:

  1. Who – Customer segmentation
  2. What – Affinity, market basket, catchment
  3. Why – Deeper research, observation, surveys

Who: Customer Segmentation

Segmentation Type Basis Examples
Demographic Geography, age, city, store Region‑based, age‑band
Behavioral Loyalty segments (green / yellow / red), life stage, channel preference, category purchase Frequent visitors vs. one‑time buyers; online‑only vs. omnichannel
Psychographic Values, attitudes, interests, beliefs, intention to recommend (NPS) Brand affinity, feedback data

What: Customer Insights from Data

  • Brand / category affinityWhich brands or categories a customer buys (e.g., only grocery from Spar, not home furniture)
  • Market Basket AnalysisProducts bought together in a single visit (from invoice data)
  • Catchment analysisWhere customers come from; how far they travel to a store; differences between online and offline categories

Why: Deeper Research

  • Market researchCommissioned studies (e.g., why footfall differs between stores)
  • Observation researchIn‑store: which aisles customers visit; layout and merchandising decisions
  • Shopping journey analysisIn‑store observation or digital path‑to‑purchase analysis, supplemented with interviews
  • Satisfaction surveysAutomated post‑purchase SMS surveys
  • Competition analysisBehavior changes due to new competitors or aggressive offers

Customer Analysis & Value

Customer analysis classifies data to assess the value of each customer. Key metrics:

  • Lifetime Value (LTV)projected total value of a customer over their relationship
  • Average Bill Valueaverage spend per visit/purchase
  • Frequencynumber of purchases per year (e.g., 6, 4, 12 times)
  • Period of Engagementhow long the customer has been active; when they tend to drop off

These metrics are used to create relevant offers for each customer, aligned with:

  • Propositionwhat the customer wants (based on past purchases)
  • Great experiencee.g., personal shopper for top‑tier customers; free home delivery of altered items
  • Brand beliefconsistency with the brand’s purpose

Customer Context

Understanding context involves location, personal milestones, social events (festivals), time of day (weekday vs. weekend, peak vs. off‑peak).

Business Objectives

Objective Description
Headroom analysis Potential to grow spend (e.g., from ₹10K–12K to ₹15K–20K annually)
Channel penetration Move customers from online to offline or vice versa
Category penetration Increase spend within a category (e.g., jeans → t‑shirts, formals)
Format penetration Cross‑sell across Landmark’s formats (Spar → Home Centre → Lifestyle)

Customer Retention & Value

Driving customer centricity means considering:

  • Value proposition per target segment: product range, price quality tiers
  • Fulfillment – deliver from another store if local stock is missing
  • Shopping experience – address webrooming / showrooming (comparing online vs. store)
  • Post‑sale service – e.g., alterations for apparel; after‑sales for appliances
  • Brand purpose alignment – consistent across store brands and third‑party brands

Engagement Framework: Triggers, Next Best Action, Measurement

Using the Landmark Group example:

  1. 1Customer data + journey
  2. 2Trigger
  3. 3Predictive model: next best engagement
  4. 4Customized content / offer / experience
  5. 5Orchestrate best medium & time
  6. 6Customer response: purchase, click, etc.
  7. 7Measure & learn
Then it starts again from step 1.

Example: A personalized Dussehra promotion for a customer named Jai (“Reunite with dear ones… Max fashion”) vs. a more general festive message. The trigger could be previous purchase behavior or life stage.

Key takeaways

  • Customer data spans demographic, contact, transaction, browsing, response, feedback, complaints, social listening, partnerships, and third‑party enrichment.
  • Three fundamental questions: who (segmentation), what (affinity, basket, catchment), why (research, observation, surveys).
  • Segmentation can be demographic, behavioral (loyalty tiers, life stage, channel), or psychographic.
  • Customer analysis uses metrics like LTV, average bill, frequency, and engagement period to drive personalized value propositions.
  • Business objectives include headroom growth, channel/category/format penetration.
  • Effective engagement uses triggers, predictive models, customized offers, and measurement of response.

Customer Engagement at L'Oréal

L'Oréal, the world’s largest cosmetics company (≈€45 B, founded 1907, French), operates a complex signature‑and‑brand structure. Each signature (e.g., L’Oréal Paris, Garnier, Gemey, Lascad) contains multiple brands that compete across categories (hair care, colourants, etc.) – often without customers knowing they all belong to the same parent. A more recent classification splits the portfolio into L’Oréal Luxe (Lancôme, Giorgio Armani, YSL – premium licensed brands), Consumer Products (Garnier, Mixa, etc.), Professional Products (Kérastase, Matrix – sold to salons), and Dermatological Beauty (Vichy, La Roche‑Posay). Luxe brands contribute heavily to revenue and margins.

Blogger Panel (Micro‑Influencer Programme)

L’Oréal’s R&D Consumer Insights group recruits micro‑influencers (10 000–30 000 followers) who blog about beauty, travel, or fashion. Influencers sign a 1‑2 year contract, receive pre‑launch products, use them, and provide feedback while posting on their own channels.

Advantages Disadvantages
Connect with other bloggers; engage with followers via email campaigns Difficult to measure influencer quality
Constant interaction with the market Slow evaluation process
Easy/quick to update new posts May lack customer centricity – bloggers not necessarily representative
Quality limited by writing (or video) skills
Time to hone content and grow audience
Risk of biased or inaccurate information

Traditional Focus Groups

Standard method for large R&D‑heavy firms: gather lead users (heavy product users) in a facility for moderated discussion.

Advantages Disadvantages
Observe research in action; probe for clarification Not in natural home environment
Quick results (many respondents at once) Costly (time, travel); hard to scale
Measure customer reactions; easy to replicate across markets Small sample – may not represent whole market
Hands‑on assessment; high involvement Groupthink bias; moderator bias
Respondents may not be fully honest
Not technologically advanced

Beauty Bubble Community (Mobile App)

L’Oréal created an online community where consumers post video logs of using cosmetics in their own homes. Participants are active social‑media users who validate their expertise simply as consumers – no formal training needed.

Advantages Disadvantages
Natural setting – authentic usage Information overload if many similar posts
Validates consumer expertise
Flexible – no moderator needed; quick feedback
Allows crowdsourcing and collaborative brand‑consumer work
Easy to expand; high interaction; free (positive & negative) feedback
Increases customer retention/loyalty; improves brand image
Early trend detection (thought leadership)

Key takeaways

  • L’Oréal uses three complementary engagement methods: blogger panels, focus groups, and an online video community.
  • Blogger panels rely on micro‑influencers – moderate following, but risk bias.
  • Focus groups are quick and hands‑on but artificial and expensive.
  • The Beauty Bubble community provides authentic, natural‑setting feedback at scale, though it can generate information overload.

Customer Co‑Creation for Innovation – Customization

Customer insights and engagement lead to co‑creation – using one‑to‑one digital interaction to improve existing products or create new ones. The concept of mass customization combines economies of scale (“mass”) with individual tailoring (“customization”).

Customization in Wealth Management

The table shows how different firms allocate decision rights between the firm and the customer across wealth‑management activities.

Activity KARVY (100% firm) ICICI Direct (mixed)
Research on asset class Firm 100% Firm 50%, Customer 50%
Deciding fund allocation Firm 100% Customer 100%
Investment order execution Firm 100% Firm 100%
Reporting & portfolio monitoring Firm 100% Firm 20%, Customer 80%

Asset classes include equity, gold ETF, mutual funds, commodities, forex, debt instruments. KARVY does everything; ICICI Direct lets customers control allocation and monitoring.

The 2×2 Mass Customization Framework

Four types defined by whether the product changes and whether its representation (presentation/packaging) changes.

Product changes? Representation changes? Type Key Idea Example
No No Adaptive customization Standard product, user alters settings Lutron lights – programmable scenes (party, reading)
No Yes Cosmetic customization Standard product, different packaging/presentation for each customer Starbucks calling your name; Planters packing same coffee under different labels for retailers
Yes No Transparent customization Product customized for each customer without them knowing ChemStation – salespeople observe factory cleaning needs, deliver tailored chemical package in standard container
Yes Yes Collaborative customization Dialogue with customer to define needs; both product and representation changed Paris Miki (eyewear) – online tools to design lens power, shape, and frame; Lenskart in India

Key takeaways

  • Mass customization = standard production + individual tailoring.
  • The framework classifies by product change and representation change.
  • Four types: adaptive (user‑tweaked settings), cosmetic (same product, different packaging), transparent (hidden individualisation), collaborative (co‑designed via dialogue).
  • Wealth management illustrates varying degrees of customer decision rights across activities.
  • All customization depends on customers sharing information – either actively through tools or passively through observation.

Mass Customization & Co-Production

Mass customization is the ability to provide individually designed products and services to every customer through high process agility, flexibility, and integration – at a cost comparable to mass production.

Co-production is the strategy firms use to meet customization requirements. It requires customers to actively participate in creating the core offering – through inventiveness, co-design, or shared production.

  • Mass customization takes the customer’s perspective (getting a tailored product).
  • Co-production takes the firm’s perspective (enabling the customization by co-opting customer competence).

Critical Success Factors (Elements of Mass Customization)

Element Description Example
Elicitation Mechanism for interacting with customers and obtaining specific information – name, address, choices, physical measurements, reactions to prototypes. Raymonds suit: fabric, fit, accessories measured; trial of half-complete garment for alterations.
Process flexibility Production technology must fabricate the product according to the information gathered. Cell manufacturing systems.
Logistics Subsequent processing and distribution that maintain each item’s identity to deliver the right product to the right customer – often direct-to-customer (D2C). Dell: upfront payment, address, custom build delivered to the correct buyer.

Limits of Mass Customization

  • Requires a highly flexible production technology (e.g., cell manufacturing).
  • Requires an elaborate system for eliciting customer needs and wants.
  • Requires a strong direct-to-customer (D2C) logistics system (now widely available).
  • Requires sufficient customers willing to pay a premium for customization.

Forms of Co-Production (Typology)

Co-production can be classified by:

  1. Stage of customer activation – design, production, assembly, distribution, usage.
  2. Type of customer effort – sharing information/expertise vs. undertaking physical or mental effort.

The spectrum ranges from adaptive customization (customer adjusts a standard product) through to co-design and collaborative customization (customer directly shapes the offering).

Key takeaways – Mass Customization

  • Mass customization aims to deliver tailored products at mass-production costs.
  • Co-production is the customer‑involvement strategy that enables it.
  • Three pillars: elicitation, process flexibility, logistics.
  • Limits include technological, logistical, and customer willingness to pay.

The IKEA Effect

The IKEA effect is the tendency to value self‑made products more highly than identical products made by others – “labour leads to love.”

In this demonstration:

  1. A handmade table is shown in isolation (ask willingness to pay).
  2. A reference table at ₹9,000 is shown (the original table’s perceived value changes).
  3. The table is revealed to be your own creation – built over 12 weekends (3 months, 3 hours each Saturday) with provided materials. Willingness to pay increases significantly.

Why Labour Leads to Love

  • Effort justification – people rationalise the effort they invested by assigning higher value to the outcome.
  • Studies show: participants see their own (even amateurish) creations as equal in value to expert creations.
  • They also expect others to share that opinion.

Who Is Affected?

The IKEA effect applies to both DIY‑enthusiasts and novices – no difference in valuation increase.

The Paradox of Work

People rate jobs as among the least pleasurable activities, yet also among the most rewarding. This apparent contradiction is explained by effort justification: the effort itself creates a sense of reward.

The principle extends beyond products: students who invest more effort in learning often perceive greater value in the knowledge they create.

Key takeaways – IKEA Effect

  • Self‑made products are valued higher (labour → love).
  • Effect depends on successful completion of the task.
  • Driven by effort justification – effort and valuation increase together.
  • Applies to both experienced DIYers and novices.
  • Explains why effortful but unpleasant tasks (e.g., jobs) are simultaneously seen as rewarding.

LEGO: Fan‑Led Co‑Creation & Co‑Production

LEGO, a family‑held Danish company, used customer‑led innovation to revive its fortunes. Its official objectives: create innovative play experiences and reach more children; growth is a by‑product, not a financial target.

How Customer Co‑Production Transformed LEGO

Initiative Year Description Key Outcome
LEGO Mindstorms 1998 Robotics platform with MIT Media Lab; first hybrid digital‑physical experience. First time adult fans were brought into design. Pioneered co‑creation with users.
LEGO Architecture 2009 (grassroots) Adult fan (architect Adam Reed Tucker) built iconic building replicas. LEGO employees secretly provided bricks; he produced 200 boxes of Sears & Hancock Towers. Sold in local shops at 70(vs.70 (vs. 30 for a kid’s kit). Proved adult‑fan market viability → official LEGO Architecture line.
LEGO CUUSOO / LEGO Ideas 2008 (Japan) → 2011 (global) Crowdsourcing site: super‑fans suggest sets; others vote; 10,000 votes triggers review; LEGO produces limited editions. Created kits like Back to the Future DeLorean, Ghostbusters Ectomobile, Female Scientist lab, Big Bang Theory apartment.
LEGO Fusion ~2013 Hybrid digital‑physical: build model, take photo with tablet → becomes part of virtual world. Four versions ($34.99 each). Evolved from Life of George; focus on how kids play.
LEGO Games 2010–2013 20 board games combining traditional gameplay with bricks. Discontinued – not all initiatives succeed.

The Stealthy Start of LEGO Architecture

  • Adam Reed Tucker (architect, Chicago) approached LEGO with his homemade iconic‑building models.
  • LEGO’s target was boys 5–11; adults were a “no‑go.”
  • Internal champion (David Graham, Future Labs) made a counter‑offer: provide bricks, let Tucker produce small batches.
  • First 200 boxes sold in local shops – and at a premium price.
  • Proved the business case → official line launched.

Digital Enablement – The “Phygital” Shift

Later projects like LEGO Fusion and Life of George (2012) blend physical bricks with smartphone/tablet apps – a phygital experience. These initiatives were developed by Future Labs, the R&D unit that studies play patterns.

Key takeaways – LEGO Case

  • Customer co‑production can create entirely new product lines (LEGO Architecture, LEGO Ideas).
  • Success often starts with a small, stealthy test before scaling.
  • Not every customer‑led initiative survives (LEGO Games discontinued).
  • Digital tools (apps, cameras) enable new forms of co‑production (phygital experiences).
  • When customers are empowered as co‑creators, they are willing to pay a premium.

Customer Co-Creation for Innovation

Customer co‑creation is the practice of leveraging customer insights to develop new products, engage broader audiences, and grow the business. Companies like LEGO, Barilla, and Salesforce illustrate how firms orchestrate customer input through digital platforms, social media, and dedicated co‑creation programs.

The Barilla Case Study: “In the Mill I Wish For” (MIW)

Barilla, a 170‑year‑old Italian pasta manufacturer, launched a community‑based co‑creation initiative called “In the Mill I Wish For” (MIW). The initiative was studied using primary data (semi‑structured interviews with managers, internal documents) and secondary data (press releases, case studies).

The MIW process evolved over time across five dimensions:

Dimension Past Present (at time of study)
Purpose Obtain feedback on existing initiatives; gather incremental new ideas. Also obtain radically new ideas from a larger, more diverse community.
Place Web 2.0 portal, Facebook account, company website, RSS feed of MIW blog. Same channels maintained.
Principles MIW does not teach – it learns. A listening, learning platform for genuine interaction. No change.
Procedures Registration, submitting ideas, voting; top‑voted ideas enter NPD evaluation. Added: tutor assistance, brand‑manager polls (quantitative & qualitative, stratified by age), free‑product rewards, weekly reviews, monthly newsletters to BD&I team, periodic company‑wide reviews.
Practitioners MIW customers (mill customers), DC employees. Added brand managers and business development/innovation managers.

Outcome: New products, customized pasta on digital platforms, and overall business growth – similar to LEGO’s co‑creation success.

Innovation in the Digital Economy: Antecedents and Consequences

A framework based on big data investments identifies drivers and outcomes of service innovation:

  • Big Data Marketing Affordances – possibilities for action enabled by big data technology and analytics for customer‑focused goals. They include:
    • Customer behaviour pattern spotting
    • Real‑time market responsiveness
    • Data‑driven market ambidexterity
  • Service innovation leads to customer value benefits (convenience, engagement, etc.), which in turn affect shareholder value.
  • Moderators: industry digitalization; purchase stage (pre‑/post‑purchase); product nature (utilitarian vs. hedonic).

Digital Capabilities and Customer Experience

A broader digital capability framework includes: business model, customer experience, operations, employee experience, and digital platform. For co‑creation, the customer experience dimension is key and comprises:

  • Customer experience design
  • Customer intelligence (collecting and incorporating insights)
  • Emotional engagement

Co‑creation requires integrating customer intelligence into experience design.

Salesforce Ignite: B2B Co‑creation through Design Thinking

Salesforce, a CRM platform, launched the Salesforce Ignite co‑creation program to convince large enterprises (already using competing CRM/ERP systems) to adopt Salesforce. Ignite uses design thinking principles in a cyclical process:

Phase Activity
Concrete Experience Observe and embed deep understanding of the customer’s environment, challenges, tools, frustrations, and opportunities.
Reflective Observation Analyze observations; notice patterns.
Abstract Conceptualization Frame and reframe assumptions – ask “why”; question current beliefs.
Active Experimentation Imagine solutions, build prototypes/pilots, test and shape – embrace failure and learn.

The cycle repeats, moving from understanding to testing. The program operates without guarantee of sale, but it generates demand, captures success stories, and attracts top internal talent.

Process flow:

  • Raise awareness (internal & client events)
  • Generate internal demand (sales team proposes Ignite)
  • Execute Ignite sessions → achieve annual customer value (CV)
  • Capture success stories → enable non‑Ignite sales
  • Attract talent and scale capacity

Key Takeaways

  • Customer co‑creation leverages customer insights for product, service, and business model innovation.
  • Barilla’s MIW evolved from incremental to radical innovation by expanding participants, processes, and practitioners.
  • Innovation in the digital economy depends on big data investments → affordances → service innovation → customer value → shareholder value, moderated by industry, purchase stage, and product type.
  • Digital capabilities for co‑creation focus on customer experience design, intelligence, and emotional engagement.
  • Salesforce Ignite demonstrates a design‑thinking co‑creation cycle for enterprise B2B customers, even before purchase.

Expert Interviews: Digital Marketing, Brand Value, and Market Digitisation

AI in Marketing: Raja Rajamannar

AI can change both the speed of marketing work and the relevance of customer communication. At Mastercard, historical RFPs, their responses, and win/loss outcomes were connected with company websites, mobile resources, repositories, and content libraries. An AI engine could produce a sensible first draft in four minutes, compared with eight weeks previously. People still reviewed and refined it over about seven and a half hours because the system was not fully accurate; finance and sales could then begin their work sooner, with submission following in two or three weeks. Mastercard was also exploring AI support for value propositions and pricing.

A proprietary digital marketing engine addressed the short life of online trends. Manual work could identify one or two trending topics, create an ad, choose placement, and test it, but the conversation might have moved by the time an optimized ad appeared. The engine predicts micro-trends that typically last less than three days, selects a relevant message, offer, or product, turns it into a banner ad, chooses a medium where the conversation is happening, and tests, optimizes, and measures ROI while predicting the next trend. Campaign effectiveness was described as four to eight times that of previously optimized approaches, enabling either lower spend for the same output or greater output for the same spend. At the time, the system was used for static communication, not video; video use was an expectation for the following 12–18 months, not a current capability.

Digital Brand Value Creation: Monappa N

Always-on digital channels reveal a customer's footprint across the purchase funnel and after purchase, when servicing and information consumption also happen online. These insights help firms refine services and identify needs that may require disruptive innovation. Gamification is one example: instead of simply copying offline discount banners online, brands used scratch cards to make an existing discount feel like a win. This brought elements of popular gaming apps into routine transactions, such as a coupon issued when a customer topped up a prepaid mobile account, increasing engagement in an otherwise commoditized experience.

Generative AI can make marketing technology smarter, support personalization, and improve go-to-market efficiency. Content teams can use tools such as ChatGPT or Gemini to generate alternatives, while skilled writers judge and refine them. Image-generation tools such as DALL·E and Midjourney can give designers many visual options to finish. The work can therefore shift from producing every item from scratch toward selecting and refining useful outputs.

Digital data also supports more developed customer lifetime value (CLV) measurement. Mature companies may compare the downstream value of actions such as downloading an app versus using a mobile website, buying pet food versus diapers, or joining a loyalty programme. These differences inform investment in loyalty and customer acquisition. Startups may use a shorter horizon, such as current profitability or the next six to twelve months of customer value, because their funding and valuation runways differ. In either case, expected downstream value helps determine how much to invest to acquire customers for different actions and categories, and guards against acquiring a customer mix that does not produce the intended value.

Performance marketing makes it possible to measure and optimize activity through the digital funnel, but last-click measurement can obscure the contribution of brand building. Brand and performance activity work together: tests by more evolved companies found a disproportionate lift when a brand campaign preceded a performance campaign, compared with either alone. Connecting them takes strategic patience and intent. Consolidated dashboards can reveal brand-level links—for example, declining brand awareness alongside declining performance efficiency—that channel-by-channel adjustments may miss.

Digital feedback has made A/B testing common, and results can arrive within 24 hours, compared with a much longer offline research cycle. However, frequency does not guarantee rigor: a simple 50/50 split may fail to control for whether the two audience groups are comparable. The quality of experimental design varies across organizations.

Marketing careers also benefit from broader product marketing skills. As experiences span digital and physical touchpoints, marketers can shape customer outcomes by improving the product experience, not only by communicating through a channel.

Market Digitisation and Brand Relevance: Tuhin Sen

Brands face influence from many sources, so marketers must distinguish primary, secondary, tertiary, and diffuse audiences. Positioning must respond to social context as well as product attributes. Coca-Cola's positioning around joy, for example, offers a frame beyond a direct health claim when concerns about sugar and its impacts make such a claim difficult to defend.

Digital financial services create value when the promise matches the experience. Paytm's convenience—making a payment without the stress of a physical bank interaction—helped its adoption; QR payments illustrate how India's digital public infrastructure can be both created and communicated so people adopt it. Electric vehicles show that social value alone may not overcome customer economics: high prices, charging-station availability, and battery costs can make adoption difficult when customers are unwilling to pay extra for environmental benefits. Adoption can therefore vary by category and change as social context changes.

Brand management combines science and art. Consumer psychology and behavioral economics help explain how brands reduce perceived risk and provide functional and emotional value. That residual value may be difficult to quantify and can conflict with short-term performance-marketing measures. A brand that occupies a place in a customer's mind—illustrated by the Porsche advertising line that it may not be in the garage but is in the mind—has built mental presence; the idea of a lovemark expresses a deeper emotional connection.

Key takeaways – Expert Interviews

  • AI can accelerate RFP drafting and make trend-responsive advertising more relevant, while human review remains part of the workflow.
  • Digital footprints inform service improvement, personalization, customer-value investment, and brand-performance measurement.
  • Brand building and performance marketing can reinforce each other; last-click measures can miss that connection.
  • Digital A/B testing is widespread, but balanced audiences and sound experimental design still matter.
  • Market context, customer economics, psychology, and product experience all shape brand relevance and adoption.

The Ansoff Matrix

The Ansoff Growth Matrix classifies growth opportunities along two dimensions: product (existing vs. new) and market (existing vs. new). Intuitively, it helps a firm decide where to focus its resources: stick with what it knows, innovate, expand, or take a leap into the unknown.

Market Penetration

Existing products, existing markets. The firm stays in the same cities/segments and tries to increase its market share (e.g., from 25 % to higher). Tactics: expand distribution, run promotions, increase loyalty.

Example: Fashion brand Ajio targeting college students in big cities. It keeps its current product line (jeans, t‑shirts) and works on gaining a larger share of those same cities.

Product Development

New products, existing markets. The firm introduces new offerings to the same customer base and geography. Customer insights and co‑creation fuel innovation.

Example: Ajio adds jackets and other apparel to its college‑student product range while still selling in the same cities.

Market Development

Existing products, new markets. The firm takes current products into different geographies or new customer segments (e.g., younger teens, small islands, new countries). Digital tools often enable this expansion.

Example: Ajio sells its standard jeans and t‑shirts to younger children by repackaging or adjusting sizes.

Diversification

New products, new markets. The riskiest strategy, as both dimensions are unfamiliar. Often pursued when existing opportunities are saturated.


Assessing Opportunities: The MARAKA Framework

Firms like HubSpot (an inbound marketing SaaS company) use the MARAKA framework to evaluate market‑development opportunities:

Component What it measures Example metrics for HubSpot
Market Availability Market size and potential # SMEs in target country, potential revenue ($2.5 B total; 230 k+ customers)
Real‑time Analytics Current traction in that market Local traffic, lead generation, close rates, retention, churn
Customer Addressability Ease of entry and fit Integration with local payment systems, product localization, legal requirements, partner needs

The freemium model (e.g., Asana) provides real‑time analytics: a company with 100 free users from the same IP is a qualified lead → pre‑sales initiates conversion to paid enterprise licenses.


Case Study: Unilever International (UI)

Unilever ($61 B turnover, >400 brands, 13 “super‑brands” >$1 B each) created Unilever International (UI) to capture white spaces – non‑core brands, underserved segments, new channels (airports, cruise ships, duty‑free), and small geographies that local operating companies ignore.

Phase Period Turnover goal Result
UI 1.0 2012–2016 250 M→250\,M \to 500 M Doubled in <4 years; 15‑person Singapore team managing 100+ markets via partnerships and digital
UI 2.0 2016–2019 500 M→500\,M \to 1 B Doubled ahead of plan; won Unilever Global Compass Award 2019
UI 3.0 Post‑2019 1 B→1\,B \to 2 B Focus on capability scaling, digital marketing, partner networks, intrapreneur culture

Key enablers: digital communication, outsourced partners (gig workers, agencies), repositioning and repackaging existing brands for new markets.


Leveraging Digital for Market Development: The OIEO Framework

Research (published in Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science) distinguishes B2C vs. B2B digital marketing in emerging and developed economies. A core conceptual model is OIEO – Owned, Inbound, Earned, Organic media.

  • Firm‑initiated: Paid media (sponsored ads), owned media (website, properties), inbound marketing (content that attracts visitors).
  • Market‑initiated: Earned media (likes, shares, comments), organic search (indexed search, Google Trends).

Key Research Findings (B2B in emerging markets)

  • Owned media has a strong positive association with new sales.
  • Earned social media has a positive but low impact on new sales.
  • Paid media elasticities for new sales and customer acquisition are on average negative – more spend does not proportionally increase outcomes.
  • Inbound marketing plays a critical role in sales and customer acquisition.
  • Feedback loops exist between digital media investments and performance; effects cannot be isolated.

Key Takeaways

  • The Ansoff Matrix classifies growth into penetration, product development, market development, and diversification.
  • Market development (existing products, new markets) can be assessed with frameworks like MARAKA (Market Availability, Real‑time Analytics, Customer Addressability).
  • Unilever International demonstrates how a dedicated small unit using digital tools can capture white spaces and double revenue rapidly.
  • Digital market development relies on a mix of POEM (Paid, Owned, Earned Media) plus organic search; owned media and inbound content have the strongest impact on new sales.
  • Paid media often shows negative elasticity – more spending does not guarantee proportional gains.
Revise before your examAll 12 exam tips from this module in one list
  1. The framework explicitly shows that firm performance is not directly caused by engagement marketing; it is mediated by customer engagement and moderated by what the customer already brings (resources). A highly engaged customer with few network assets may not improve firm performance as much.
  2. Distinguish transaction models (focus on purchase behavior) from engagement models (focus on non-transactional contributions like sharing, reviewing, community participation). Engagement models often require specialized distributions (zero-inflated, truncated) because many customers contribute zero.
  3. The "weak link" concept – a customer who connects two otherwise separate networks – can be more valuable than a hub for reaching new communities (the surprising strength of weak links).
  4. The key is the closed loop: data → insight → engagement → response → data refinement. Focus on how the three questions (who, what, why) feed into segmentation, then into predictive next‑best‑action.
  5. Collaborative customization** is the highest level because it alters both product and representation through direct customer dialogue. It requires tools that allow customers to articulate and visualise their preferences.
  6. The two terms are complementary. Co-production is the mechanism; mass customization is the outcome.
  7. The effect is strongest when the creation is successfully completed. If the task is unfinished or the creation destroyed, the effect disappears.
  8. LEGO’s story illustrates how customers can drive innovation when firms are willing to listen, even to non‑target segments. The key lesson: co‑production need not be limited to individual product customisation – it can extend to new product development (crowdsourcing, fan‑led design). The firm’s role is to provide the platform and production capability.
  9. Salesforce Ignite is a B2B co‑creation example using design thinking before the customer signs up. Contrast with Barilla’s B2C community‑based model.
  10. Separate the speed of digital measurement from the rigor of the method. Fast feedback and frequent A/B tests do not by themselves establish a reliable causal result.
  11. MARAKA is a real‑world tool used by SaaS companies. Be able to define each component and relate it to digital market expansion.
  12. For B2B market development in emerging economies, investing in owned media and inbound content is more effective than pouring money into paid advertising. Always consider the circular, interconnected nature of digital media.

Test yourself on this module

Questions from these notes, one at a time, with feedback. Your weak topics are saved.

Set it up free Takes about a minute. Free plans work.